Kudos to the Supreme Court to have stayed the Uttarakhand High Court's verdict which had set aside President's Rule and restored the dislodged Harish Rawat govt ....
This unethical atomistic ruling was delivered despite the established impression that the Rawat govt had lost the trust of a majority in the House ...
Clearly the High Court appears of not to have taken a holistic view on the vexed issue ...
What are the facts to justify my claim that the ruling was atomistic, not holistic?
The HC did not take into consideration the ugly developments leading to the imposition of President's Rule by the centre ...
What were the developments?
1) The opposition of nine of the ruling party's Legislators to a money Bill
2) Speaker refusing to meet a majority demand for a division in passing the money Bill
3) The disqualification of nine MLAs by the Speaker before a trust vote was to be taken by the Rawat govt ...
Pause
Also, the HC did not address the rebel Congress legislators' grievance
So, it was inapproriate of the HC to have taken an atomistic view and deliver the judgement, even before it could pass a final verdict or even interim orders ...
However, I am of the view that though it is worth looking into the unconstitutional reasons given by the Governor in support of imposition of President’s rule, the centre needs to answer the logic behind imposing president’s rule a day before the floor test
It should also explain why it did not approach the court against the speaker’s decision"
Modi Government should be careful to see - it must not make President's Rule the norm in the days to come ...
Interested in Poetry?
Log on to: http://bdnarayankar20.blogspot.in/
Also Check In: https://www.facebook.com/Chandini-You-are-all-my-reasons-1000671170022830/
Want To Buy My Maiden Book Chandini - You Are All My Reasons?
Please Get In Touch With Me: 7259135481
No comments:
Post a Comment